IFAC SMP Committee Response to the IESBA: Proposed Revisions to the Non-Assurance Services
The no tolerance stance (i.e., outright removal of the materiality threshold) proposed by IESBA for PIEs (and, for some services, also applies to the non-PIEs) is based on the argument that perception of independence in appearance is key, whereas the IESBA’s mechanism has been the application of the reasonable and informed third party test, which was designed for this purpose and is instead being overridden. A third-party test might not lead to the same outcome as a no stance approach in all cases as the former allows for flexibility.