Reinventing ERM and Internal Audit: Accountants Need to Drive Radical Change

Tim J. Leech FCPA FCA CIA CCSA CRMA | April 11, 2017 | 1

The speed and magnitude of change in the world continues to accelerate. Companies that were once leaders in their sector, including Kodak, Blackberry, Sears, and Macy’s, have suffered massive declines in value and sector status. Whole industries, like taxi cabs, travel, and retail, have seen massive business model shifts with the arrival of game changing players like Uber and Amazon. Most recently, customer feedback from multiple sources is strongly signalling that enterprise risk management (ERM) and internal audit need to radically change their core business models or risk similar fates. Accountants serving as board directors, CEOs, CFOs, controllers, and chief audit executives need to play lead roles driving radical change to better meet the needs of their companies and boards.

The problems with the traditional internal audit business model, a model where well-intending auditors assess a small percentage of the total risk universe each year and form subjective opinions on internal control “effectiveness”, continue to grow as the needs of management, boards and other stakeholders escalate exponentially.  ERM processes, which are often an annual or semi-annual exercise to update risk registers created as a response to regulatory compliance requirements, are now expected to help boards meet escalating demands for effective board oversight of risk processes, risk culture, and risk appetite and tolerance. Traditional risk-centric, risk-register based ERM is ill-equipped to provide a robust response to these new expectations. 

What’s the Solution?

The natural inclination of people faced with growing evidence that status quo methods and business models need to change radically is to propose slow and incremental changes in hopes that small tweaks will do the job. It won’t. Quantum changes in status quo ERM and internal audit business models and methods, similar to those being driven by Uber and Amazon, are needed.

We believe the solution to growing dissatisfaction in ERM and internal audit products and services is a simple one, but recognize that human resistance to radical change is often daunting. We call the new approach Objective-Centric ERM and Internal Audit.

Unlike traditional approaches to internal audit and ERM, this approach focuses on populating an entity level Objectives Register with an organization’s top value creation and preservation objectives and assigning an Owner/Sponsor to each objective to report residual risk status upward. The role of ERM specialists is to build and maintain the ERM framework and help Owner/Sponsors assess and report upward to the board. The role of internal audit is to report to senior management and the board on the reliability of the ERM framework and the residual risk status reports provided by Owner/Sponsors. Details on the approach, deficiencies of current approaches to ERM and internal audit, the business case for change, and training/reference aids are beyond the scope of this short article. They are available as free open source resources for end users on our website. 

Objective-Centric ERM and Internal Audit Process Overview

Accountants around the world can, and must as true professionals, play leadership roles to drive the changes necessary to meet the assurance needs of key stakeholders and societies we live in. For organizations willing to challenge the status quo, it is possible to produce far more value from the hundreds of billions of dollars currently being spent globally on traditional ERM and internal audit. Will you help drive change?

 

Tim J. Leech FCPA FCA CIA CCSA CRMA

Managing Director, Risk Oversight Solutions Inc.

Tim J. Leech FCPA FCA CIA CCSA CRMA is Managing Director at Risk Oversight Solutions Inc., which focuses on helping companies implement objective-centric enterprise risk management (ERM) and internal audit to meet escalating board risk oversight expectations and add real value. He has over 30 years of global experience in the board risk oversight, ERM, internal audit, and forensic accounting fields, including expert witness testimony in civil and criminal proceedings. He has provided training for hundreds of thousands of public and private sector board members, senior executives, professional accountants, auditors and risk management specialists in Canada, the US, the EU, Australia, South America, Africa, and the Middle and Far East. He has received worldwide recognition as a pioneer, thought leader, and trainer. His article “Reinventing Internal Audit” featured in the April 2015 issue of Internal Audit received the 2016 Outstanding Contributor award from the Institute of Internal Auditors. He is a regular contributor to Ethical Boardroom and Conference Board Director Notes, including his newest ground breaking article, “Focusing ERM and Internal Audit on What Really Matters: Long Term Value Creation and Preservation”. He can be contacted at timleech@riskoversightsolutions.com.

Join the Conversation (1)

To leave a comment below, login or register with IFAC.org

 

Stathis Gould April 18, 2017

I see the role of accountants being described here as an important part of their role in bringing about the integrated thinking that underpins Integrated Reporting, which ultimately is a tool for responsible capitalism helping organizations operate effectively in a complex, competitive, and resource constrained world. CFOs in particular are skeptical of perpetually increasing regulatory and compliance requirements and can encourage objective-centric ERM as a key element of their business partnership role.

Thank you for your interest in our publications. These valuable works are the product of substantial time, effort and resources, which you acknowledge by accepting the following terms of use. You may not reproduce, store, transmit in any form or by any means, with the exception of non-commercial use (e.g., professional and personal reference and research work), translate, modify or create derivative works or adaptations based on such publications, or any part thereof, without the prior written permission of IFAC.

Our reproduction and translation policies, as well as our online permission request and inquiry system, are accessible on the Permissions Information web page.

For additional information, please read our website Terms of Use. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.